Superior FCU: A Mortgage Market Leader

Superior Federal Credit Union granted 25% of mortgages in Lima, OH, in 2010.

 
 

Over the past five years, credit unions have expanded their mortgage lending efforts. Much of the sustained activity has been based in refinancing of existing debt. However at some point, home prices will stabilize and buyers will return to markets. In advance of a shift from a refinance-driven market to a purchase-driven market, credit unions focused on mortgage lending will need to take action in order to build their lending capabilities and reputations in their communities.

A starting point for credit unions to move toward a more purchase-driven market is looking at their local market data. Understanding local market analytics, evaluating competitors, and measuring volume are all critical to generating and maintaining market share for area consumers’ mortgages. To effectively serve consumers, an institution must be able to answer these questions:

  • What is the size of my market(s)? Is it growing?
  • Who are the dominant players? Are there any newcomers to observe?
  • Which institutions are gaining or losing market share?
  • Are there steps in our mortgage lending process that can be improved upon?

Data from Call Reports (5300) is limited in detail and only has data for credit unions, a small segment of the mortgage lending marketplace. Another source of data, the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data, provides additional detail for all mortgage financiers, including non-depository institutions by county and MSA. Now available through Callahan & Associates’ Mortgage Analyzer, this data can answer the above questions and more.

Snapshot of a Marketplace: Lima, OH

Lima is a city in northwestern Ohio, about halfway between Toledo and Dayton and with a population of just under 39,000. Six credit unions are headquartered there. One of these institutions, Superior Federal Credit Union ($377M) files HMDA data. A closer look at the Lima, Ohio marketplaces with Mortgage Analyzer reveals a compelling story for Superior FCU.

Market Share for Purchase, First Lien, Owner-Occupied Mortgages
For The Top 3 Lenders In Lima, Ohio | Data as of December 31, 2010
Callahan & Associates' Market Share for Purchase, First Lien, Owner-Occupied Mortgages in Lima Ohio for Top 3 Lenders
Source: Callahan & Associates' Mortgage Analyzer.

In 2010, financial institutions and mortgage companies granted $284 million in mortgage loans for homes in Lima, Ohio. Like the majority of markets, most of the loans ($213 million or 75%) were for re-finances of existing debt. The purchase money in Lima totaled $69 million. Superior FCU funded 627 mortgage loans in 2010, nearly twice the mortgages of its closest competitor, Citizens National Bank, which funded 372 loans.

Lima, in contrast to some larger markets, is concentrated. The top three lenders funded 52.9% of all mortgages. Both community banks and national institutions re-gained market share lost in 2009. JP Morgan Chase, The Huntington National Bank, First National Bank of Pandora, and Wells Fargo/Wachovia all gained more than 100 basis points in 2010.

For each of the past four years, Superior FCU has retained the highest market share. Though its market share slipped in 2010, this may have been due to a strategic management decision. After significant gains in 2009, Superior FCU executives may have taken a step back to monitor the portfolio, manage their balance sheet, or develop a new product to serve the marketplace.

Superior denies a lower ratio of loans (14.5%) than their banks’ competitors (22.3%). The credit union has a similar average funded loan amount compared to its competitors as the average loan for the credit union is just more than $114,500, compared to the banks’ $115,800. Despite similar loan amounts the credit union may be targeting a different market segment. The average gross annual income of the funded loan borrowers is about $70,000, lower than the banks $82,000.

Finally, Mortgage Analyzer data reveals that Superior FCU sold nearly all of its loans made in 2010 to GSEs.

Mortgage Market Scorecard For All Mortgage Loans
Data as of December 31, 2010
  Superior Federal Credit Union Banks & Others in Market Total Market
Basic Information
Total Number Of Loans Applied For 844 3,183 4,047
Total Approved 702 1,953 2,669
Total Denied 122 709 836
Total Funded (#) 627 1,825 2,465
Total Funded ($000s) $71,859 $211,383 $284,108
Key Ratios
Approved/Applications Ratio 83.18% 61.36% 65.95%
Funded/Applications 74.29% 57.34% 60.91%
Funded/Approved 89.32% 93.45% 92.36%
% Of Loan Denied 14.45% 22.27% 20.66%
% Of Funded Loan -
Owner Occupied (Primary)
96.81% 92.38% 93.55%
Average Funded Loan Amount (000s) $114.61 $115.83 $115.26
Average Gross Annual Income
of Funded Loans (000s)
$70.19 $81.87 $78.76
Average Gross Annual Income
of Denied Loans (000s)
$54.01 $55.01 $54.92
Loan Type
% Of Funded Loan - Conventional 98.56% 81.92% 86.25%
% Of Funded Loan - FHA-Insured 0.00% 13.81% 10.22%
% Of Funded Loan - VA-Guaranteed 0.00% 2.85% 2.11%
% Of Funded Loan - FSA/RHS 1.44% 1.42% 1.42%
Property Type
% Of Funded Loan - 1-4 Family 99.84% 98.90% 99.15%
% Of Funded Loan - Manufactured 0.16% 0.77% 0.61%
% Of Funded Loan - Multifamily 0.00% 0.33% 0.24%
Loan Purpose
% Of Funded Loan - Purchase 23.13% 26.68% 25.64%
% Of Funded Loan - Refinancing 76.71% 70.68% 72.29%
% Of Funded Loan - Home Improvement 0.16% 2.63% 2.07%
Purchaser Information
% Of Funded Loans Sold 91.39% 79.84% 82.47%
% Of Sold Loans Sold to GSEs 99.83% 76.80% 83.23%
Most Common Purchaser Affiliate Institution Other Purchaser Other Purchaser
Market Share
% Of Applications 20.85% 78.65% 100.00%
% Of Loans Funded 25.29% 74.40% 100.00%
Source: Callahan & Associates' Mortgage Analyzer

 

 

 

 

Feb. 6, 2012


Comments

 
 
 
  • Great article and accurate data.
    Ray Hughes
     
     
     
  • Jill, thanks for the comment and great example of what data can't tell you! The analysis in the article is for mortgages on homes in the Lima MSA. While there may be some overlap between Superior's own loans and other credit union loans made through Superior, it should be minimal within their home market. The example provided (Sturgis, SD) would not be included in the data above.
    Lydia Cole
     
     
     
  • You may want to contact Superior. Their portfolio is larger because they market to other credit unions. They offer an avenue for smaller credit unions to offer a competitive rate to their own members. For example, I live in Sturgis, SD and my CU secured an excellent mortgage rate for me with Superior.
    Jill Westendorf