10 Credit Unions That Top The Charts In Member Value

Callahan & Associates spotlights credit unions that return more value to members.

Callahan & Associates’ Return Of The Member (ROM) index offers a comprehensive view of the value of membership. The credit union member value calculation weighs three core credit union functions — savings, lending, and product usage — by taking into consideration aspects such as loan and deposit rates, the number of products and services offered, and member participation.

Credit unions across the country use their ROM score to support member-facing goals, hold staff accountable to better serve members, and demonstrate their impact on the communities they serve. ROM is a quantitative way for credit unions to show off the cooperative difference and demonstrate credit union member value.

Take a look at the top 10 credit unions in each asset range to see which ones made the leader board. If you don’t see your credit union and want to know where it ranks, contact Callahan today for your score.

 







LEADERS IN ROM SCORE
FOR U.S. CREDIT UNIONS | DATA AS OF 12.31.24
SOURCE: Callahan & Associates

$10M-$20M
$20M-$50M
$50M-$100M
$100M-$250M
$250M-$500M
$500M-$1B
$1B
Rank Name City State Total Assets ROM Score
1 M.E. Employees Wausau WI $17,894,958 100
2 Sorg Bay West Middletown> OH $11,308,763 99.78
3 Dertown School Latrobe> PA $12,003,557 99.55
4 Lithium Bessemer City NC $14,853,606 99.33
5 Mower County Employees Austin MN $12,055,331 99.11
6 Snake River Twin Falls ID $11,652,524 98.89
7 Parthenon Nashville TN $18,625,606 98.66
8 Northern Valley Grand Forks ND $19,167,184 98.44
9 Fayette Federal Employees Uniontown PA $17,276,060 98.22
10 Spokane Media Spokane WA $17,129,564 98.00
Rank Name City State Total Assets ROM Score
1 Marathon County Employees Wausau WI $42,464,911 100
2 Special Metals New Hartford NY $20,482,302 99.87
3 State Civil Service Employees Watertown NY $40,192,214 99.73
4 Materion Elmore OH $31,105,055 99.60
5 Family Focus Omaha NE $43,657,804 99.47
6 Valex Alexandria LA $42,833,308 99.33
7 Ripple Oshkosh WI $35,727,612 99.20
8 New Horizon Barberton OH $37,394,813 99.07
9 O & R Utilities Employees Monroe NY $29,796,088 98.93
10 FedTrust Memphis TN $49,786,329 98.80
Rank Name City State Total Assets ROM Score
1 United Poles Perth Amboy NJ $65,704,478 100
2 Education 1st Ogden UT $53,497,990 99.84
3 Jack Daniel Employees’ Lynchburg TN $51,347,916 99.68
4 Limestone Manistique MI $75,279,267 99.52
5 Sunset Science Park Portland OR $89,614,837 99.36
6 Windthorst Windthorst TX $90,471,929 99.20
7 South Bend Firefighters South Bend IN $58,248,968 99.04
8 Firefighters Salt Lake City UT $61,629,716 98.88
9 Gundersen La Crosse WI $60,805,466 98.72
10 Kings Peak Roosevelt UT $56,140,933 98.56
Rank Name City State Total Assets ROM Score
1 SRI Menlo Park CA $227,868,482 100
2 Utica Gas & Electric Employees New Hartford> NY $116,858,704 99.86
3 Sentry Stevens Point WI $143,349,770 99.71
4 Cedar Falls Community Cedar Falls IA $211,765,285 99.57
5 Safe Harbor Ludington MI $172,313,288 99.43
6 Lincoln Maine Lincoln ME $131,276,056 99.29
7 Saco Valley Saco ME $182,747,094 99.14
8 Aspen Rapid City SD $145,462,445 99.00
9 GECU La Crosse WI $111,382,801 98.86
10 Miami Firefighters Miami FL $180,199,621 98.72
Rank Name City State Total Assets ROM Score
1 PCM Green Bay WI $468,092,393 100
2 Assemblies of God Springfield MO $438,610,019 99.74
3 MECE Jefferson City MO $327,886,716 99.48
4 Peninsula Escanaba MI $328,893,213 99.21
5 Dirigo Lewiston ME $436,044,311 98.95
6 Library of Congress Washington DC $331,743,771 98.69
7 Benchmark West Chester PA $305,639,606 98.43
8 Acadia Fort Kent ME $3659,403,734 98.17
9 1st Community Sparta WI $266,549,608 97.91
10 Everence Lancaster PA $440,762,057 97.64
Rank Name City State Total Assets ROM Score
1 Co-Op Black River Falls WI $571,744,845 100
2 Superior Choice Superior WI $769,806,721 99.65
3 Ukrainian Selfreliance Feasterville PA $533,290,073 99.31
4 Alpena Alcona Area Alpena MI $861,392,450 98.96
5 Corda Cedar Rapids IA $686,675,853 98.62
6 Day Air Kettering OH $819,268,623 98.27
7 Westby Co-op Westby WI $948,639,606 97.92
8 Innovations Financial Panama City FL $615,037,932 97.58
9 Beehive Rexburg ID $604,239,786 97.23
10 Heartland Hutchinson KS $643,764,491 96.89
Rank Name City State Total Assets ROM Score
1 Summit Madison WI $7,458,311,100 100
2 Empeople Moline WI $2,246,287,693 99.78
3 Veridian Waterloo IA $7,960,128,611 99.56
4 Lake Michigan Grand Rapids MI $14,527,369,395 99.34
5 Michigan Schools and Government Clinton Township MI $3,895,082,533 99.12
6 CoVantage Antigo WI $3,725,346,803 98.89
7 Eastman Kingsport TN $9,097,283,047 98.67
8 Idaho Central Chubbuck ID $12,120,188,554 98.45
9 Stanford Palo Alto CA $4,331,816,368 98.23
10 Logix Valencia CA $9,726,331,677 98.01



April 11, 2025
CreditUnions.com
Scroll to Top