Different Incomes. Different Needs.

An analysis of loan portfolios for credit unions with and without a low-income designation illustrates how consumers’ income levels impact borrowing.

LOAN PORTFOLIO
FOR U.S. CREDIT UNIONS | DATA AS OF 06.30.23
© Callahan & Associates | CreditUnions.com

  • The NCUA can designate a credit union as “low income” when a majority of its members meet certain low-income criteria. This is important because member income impacts borrowing — analyzing loan portfolios based on whether a credit union caters to low-income or high-income Americans illustrates the degree of this influence.
  • Balances in the loan portfolio at U.S. credit unions have recently increased thanks to both the COVID-era boom in originations as well as the increase in interest rates that has encouraged credit unions to hold loans rather than sell to the secondary market.
  • Credit union members with higher incomes tend to take out more mortgages. Unsurprisingly, rising home prices have skewed homeownership even more toward the wealthy. Credit unions without the low-income designation hold 41.2% of their loan portfolio in mortgages versus 31.6% for low-income credit unions.
  • On the other hand, low-income credit unions hold a higher percentage of auto loans — 35.9% versus 27.8% for those without a low-income designation. Considering the rising cost of vehicles, credit union members of modest means increasingly need financing to afford transportation.
  • The asset quality of these loans has moved in tandem during the past five years, with credit unions that don’t hold a low-income designation consistently reporting delinquency rates a few basis points higher than institutions that do. In the second quarter, credit unions without a low-income designation reported a delinquency rate of 0.67%; low-income credit unions reported a delinquency of just 0.59%.
  • These delinquency numbers might seem counterintuitive; however, it is possible that credit unions with a low-income designation decrease their risk through prudent lending practices, tighter lending standards, and more tailored products.

Is Member Income Affecting Your Loan Quality?

Develop a clear picture of your credit union’s performance with a complimentary scorecard from Callahan & Associates. Armed with your desired KPIs plus a few we might suggest, you’ll be in a better position to benchmark against desired peer groups, share findings with your board, and help members reach new levels of financial stability.
Request Your Scorecard Today
Ampersand
November 6, 2023
CreditUnions.com
Scroll to Top